Hodge.

Is Luke Hodge in trouble over his bump on Mark Murphy?I think he is safe.I saw it a a two man contest nad was just unlucky thay Murphy has a broken jaw.
I think he is in more trouble with his bump on Henderson.It looks like he jumped past the ball to hit Henderson.Think he will get a couple for it.

Hodge will go no doubt, the Murphy hit was fine.. good contest. the umps should get a couple too.. 2 howlers one in Sewell holding the ball & the Mitchell throw..

Yeah as far as the umpires were concerned I thought there were some pretty ordinary displays over the weekend.

I think he will be in trouble on his Murphy collission. Both went for the ball but Hodge’s shoulder collects Murphys jaw. I would love for it to be nothing, as it was a great contest both guys going for the ball, one unlucky in coming off second best, but i think that is the way the MRP will see it. I also agree the henderson hit was a bit worse given he was past the ball etc, but the fact there was no damage to henderson will lesten the blow.

Just give Hodge one week. Just so WC dont have to verse him and i will be happy.

I think he will get more than one week.I knew someone would say just as long as he misses the Eagles game :wink:
Going to be interesting.
Did I also see where Roughhead is being looked at as well!!!Didn’t see anything from him but maybe you will be in luck Soprano and they will both miss.

Roughhead? That would be a bonus, he is playing some good footy. Not sure what incident this was…I did watch the game and dont recall anything?

But jsut had a read and it was for a sheppard on Simpson, I dont recall it and obviously wasnt much replays or talk of it during the game. Cant really comment.

Both got off..fkn unbelievable..

Hodge - repirmand for Henderson hit
Roughie - cleared for contact with simpson
Hill - cleared
Hodge - cleared for murphy contact.

My opinion is the correct outcomes. Bit dissapponited we now have to beat hawks with roughie and hodge playing haha.

Ziebell still unlucky in my opinion.

Hodge lucky over the Henderson hit for sure.

Oh well, all done and we move on, as we should. Let’s hope Hodge doesn’t change the way he plays Friday night. One of the true hard men of the game who loves to mix it and lead by example.

I agree above.He is a bloody good player.I hope he plays the same way this week as well. :wink:

I do love watching hodgey play is an absolute superstar. Just hopefully no broken jaws this week haha

Hodge has decided to take on the charge.It seems that if he accepts the reprimand he will have carry over points the next time.If he get reported around finals time and found guilty he will get two weeks regardless.If he wins this appeal his points will drop.
If he loses the challenge he get one week.

And all charges are gone.

I am not sure how this happened.

Yes it was unintentional, yes it was low impact, but it was definately high contact. Those three points equal 125 points. I am not sure which one of them was amended to be able to let him off. But hey, I did expect him to get off, happens all the time with certain players/teams.

Sucks we now have to take on the Hawks with Hodge, but the positive is we get to watch Hodge play!!

I think they made the point that he was avoiding Roughead and the contact was accidental.I think it depends on which view of the incident you watch Soprano.I thought he was a goner.But after viewing both visions it seem that it could be looked at in the way they saw it.
Makes the Eagles job much harder now for sure.

I watched all footage they showed, and i definately believe that he left his feet trying to avoid Roughhead. But he still hit him high with a shoulder.

I guess if someone is going to bump and unintentionally hits someone high, that is unintentional. If someone is in the congestion and he is doing an act to avoid contact and subsequently makes unintentional contact that this will be downgraded to nothing. It makes sense to me, would be a harsh penalty him getting a week for trying to not hit his own team mate, but then again he did hit the guy in the jaw with his shoulder…tough job that MRP.

What is the rules if you hit your own team mate? Say an accidental head knock?

Just a free kick for an unintentional bump causing high contact.

They would of looked at downgrading the charge by it being Reckless/Negligent, of low impact, but high contact, therefore it can be seen as just a free kick and no charge to answer.
Therefore he is now in the position of fully clear on all fronts.
Anything intentional and low impact would have been given time or Reckless/Negligent with medium impact also would have attracted a penalty.

Cheers Above and Beyond, certainly explains it for me and now definately makes sense.

How do they determine low impact? Is it what they deem from looking at the contest? The result of the impact on the opposition plaer? or a combination of both.

Henderson did get up a lil heavy and was moving his jaw like he had copped a fairly heavy hit…although from the footage I would have said that he just brushed him. It must be a combination of the two, and hence the low impact call.

As I said before as well they said that his trying to avoid contaqct with his team mate was a reason as well.