Be interesting to see what comes out of this, 6 young fellas ejected from the ground for racism…obviously not privy to know exactly what was said, but calling a player Shiraz instead of Siraj sounds like banter to me then racism…don’t condone any form of racism at all, lowest form of wit, but is this really racism if true? Especially after the Indians made a complaint earlier, surely these guys wouldn’t be so stupid and blatant to start using racist remarks in public. Fine line this as the racist card can be used so easily today, India obviously got their backs up and looking for some sort of justice for their poor showing on day 3 & 4.
A couple of spectators said that it was just banter. If this article is true, you’re spot on. Maybe they were just sooking??
Why even call out anything at all?
Just watch the bloody cricket for godsake, they are bloody lucky to be even there!
Could say the same at the footy then BH…pretty sure the umps get worse at the footy and folk don’t get frog marched out…if they did, grounds would be empty by 1/4 time…
Racism is like a buffet…you can pick and choose…and you can dine out on it. If these guys have done wrong then fair due, make an example of them…however if Siraj is crying wolf, then surely he should be made an example of too…players are happy to take the plaudits and the perks to go with it, then they should be ok for some piss taking if they drop a catch, fumble whilst fielding or get smoked for runs when bowling…no different to sledging…just what home crowd advantage enables some 13th man sledging from the crowd to get in a players head…as long as it’s not referring to ones colour, culture or person.
It’s probably a case of the straw that broke the Camels back by the sounds of it. Probably has been some racial sledging leading up to it and Siraj has just had enough and reacted. I think sledging a player who has to stand stationary in a fielding position on the boundary for 6 balls an over is a bit weak and a lot different from sledging a footballer who is one of 18 opposition players out on the field and in a particular spot for a maybe a few seconds although full backs and full forwards would probably beg to differ.
Who remembers the sledging that poor old Richard Hadlee copped when he went to field at fine leg or third man? “HADLEEEEE’S A WANNNKER… HADLEEEE’S A WANNNKER…”
Why even call out anything at all?
Just watch the bloody cricket for godsake, they are bloody lucky to be even there!
[/quote]
Why? This is the same argument as the booing one. You pays yer money… so long as it’s not racial. But then, kids aren’t allowed to be told they came second, third or last, so this sort of issue will get bigger. Yer mother wears army boots…oh dear, you’ll be ok princess.
I wonder how our cricketers go in front of English, Kiwi and Saffa crowds - and vice versa?
Why? This is the same argument as the booing one. You pays yer money… so long as it’s not racial. But then, kids aren’t allowed to be told they came second, third or last, so this sort of issue will get bigger. Yer mother wears army boots…oh dear, you’ll be ok princess.
[/quote]
We are talking about proper cricket here Test cricket not Big Bash!
The BB is where you can boo to your hearts content, wear a lame Hawaiian shirt, don a moronic KFC bucket head and start a silly Mexican wave! :whistle: :woohoo:
From my understanding, the guys ejected from the ground was because of a bit of banter and nothing more. Security becoming a bit touchy maybe? Having said that, not sure what happened prior in the day or the other days? If there was prior racial abuse, why were people not escorted from the ground on other days?
With Australia’s border “supposedly closed”, I would be suggesting the indian cricketers and the cricket spectatators can thank their lucky stars the test matches are proceeding. As someone suggested earlier, why are the crowd saying anything?
They should be appreciative the damn cricket is being played.
I think we are all guilty of yelling something at the footy directed at a player whether it’s just trying to be funny or expressing anger or trying to put a player off but cricket is a completely different game where players in the outfield are stationary and close to hundreds of spectators on their own.
I think that is far more intimidating and that is the object of some of these spectators. On 9 News some vision was shown from peoples phones, one spectator was yelling for him to come closer. Why?
Just appreciate they are here giving their all and giving us a great contest, cheer your loudest and sing a few songs but show the players the respect they deserve.
Why does this remind one of Sonny Bill Williams masks and South Africa?
Why? This is the same argument as the booing one. You pays yer money… so long as it’s not racial. But then, kids aren’t allowed to be told they came second, third or last, so this sort of issue will get bigger. Yer mother wears army boots…oh dear, you’ll be ok princess.
[/quote]
We are talking about proper cricket here Test cricket not Big Bash!
The BB is where you can boo to your hearts content, wear a lame Hawaiian shirt, don a moronic KFC bucket head and start a silly Mexican wave! :whistle: :woohoo:
[/quote]
What a holier than thou response. What’s it like up there on your holy mountain bh?
Pretty sure the WAFL umps get abused more then some guy standing on his tod for 6 balls at a time at fine leg…don’t see folk getting escorted out of the ground…if it’s racial taunting then yeah chuck out the offenders…if it’s not then use it as a motivation to take a great catch, take a few wickets etc…
Be interesting to see what happens if the Barmy Army are allowed next year…Will they be escorted before drinks on day 1 for giving Starc a hard time at fine leg?
It’s funny how this all seemed to happen straight after Green had hit him for 2 sixes in the previous over. Gee I hope someone didn’t say bring him on from both ends.
Well it backfired on the Aussies big time, the sledging from Paine was pathetic and his role as captain has to come into question and Steve Smith should never be considered for the captains role ever again. When you are starting to sledge your opponent you are letting your opponent know you doubt your own ability to defeat them fair and square.
It’s a bad example for young players like Cameron Green and Will Purcovski. I have noticed when Green ducks under a bouncer he never looks up at the bowler, just keeps his head down at the pitch leaving the bowler to look at the top of his helmet. I hope he keeps that up.
From what I heard and I’ll stand corrected, there language was along the lines of calling them “street shitters” and “monkeys”, if correct then definitely racist and they should be kicked out and banned. But … we must remember the Indian home crowds calling Symonds "monkey boy’ not so long ago. They need to also clean their own house before asking us to clean ours.
Paine deserves a kick in the arse without a doubt. Very poor showing there.
Seems though that the Aussies have a target on their backs. Other international teams seem to be allowed to tamper with the ball etc, their crowds can abuse to the point of racism with little if any recourse…unless of course you are Australian.
They need an experienced player to replace Paine. Smith should be placed on a final warning, one made public. I would make either S E Marsh or Heneriques the next captain. Both would do better than Wade and Head.
I think Paine should be encouraged to bow out after the Brisbane test. He came in to soften the team’s image after the ball-tampering scandal, but now he’s not even doing that. He has done a passable job overall, but his captaincy in the Stokes test was deplorable and his keeping in Sydney equally bad. Of the current team, only Cummins appeals as a possible captain. If not, Alex Carey comes in. We obviously need a good middle order batsman. Head and Wade don’t seem to be the answer, but I don’t know who is putting their hand up at Shield level. Ark, Marsh is 37 and Henriques 34, no point bringing in guys that age to captain the team.
Agree Ark, Smith should come in but on a very short leash. Other test nations have been very very soft on ball tampering, which is a bad thing, Australia took the correct action and sanctions but I doubt other countries would do the same to their captains as well as one of their best batsmen.