This falls at the feet of iPad McDodderald
And then his crony Bailey
The whole tour plan has been an absolute schmozz
But it’s what you eventually get when you choose low ability former players to senior roles
Both these two have to be removed and higher qualified candidates be appointed
Candidates that plan for the future
We’ll probably have to reinstate the academies now
Considering the total disregard both these two fools have had for new blood
Mate both of them are Cummins puppets, nothing more, nothing less.
The selection of Maddinson for a tour of SA, who are currently the best team in Test cricket by a decent margin and with further scope for improvement now they have settled the batting order down, off no red ball cricket for nearly 2 years and his last actual season was dropped half way through that season from NSW after averaging only in the mid teens that season was the most ridiculous selection have I ever seen in any sport played at the top level.
This was a Cummins pick no 2 ways about it, but Bailey & McDonald havent got a backbone to stand up and say no that is not the right call Patrick!
And furthermore to that ridiculous Maddinson selection for SA, in his first game back for NSW he has scored 2 & 1.
He is lucky to be playing Shield let alone Test cricket against arguably the most in form bowling attack in world cricket currently!
Cannot pick Konstas
He does not have a rock solid technique that tests require
He rarely does anything in First Class games
The recent Perth games were on good batting tracks
Look at the last 2 days
Former Test player says “ It’s terrible , un-Australian - there’s no fight whatsoever it’s disgraceful , I think it’s deplorable but the batsmen have let the bowlers down the whole series”
And Captain says “ i don’t even know what I make of that”
Seriously ?
Are you that deluded and unable to admit utter failure when it just hit you like a South African Lion pack straight in the head?
Time for a new captain too - this fool has been sniffing too much carbon monoxide from his Range Rover
BH, my take on Cummins logic on the coin toss is based on the unkown and was tongue in cheek mate…who knows what discussions went on…you, me and everyone else on here haven’t got a clue what was discussed etc…though Cummins decision was on par with Ponting’s arrogance at Edgbaston many years ago
Interesting stat though…Harmer after the first 2 tests, had taken 4 wickets @ 72…probably the Aust management /bats thought Harmer was a minimum threat…on those stats he certainly was…but after taking 10/120, Harmer had series stats of 14 wickets @ 29…in one match the fella goes from chump to champ…
I am not defending Cummins decision, but as we aren’t privy to any inside intel, the decision was made to bowl…as a fan, I can only support the team selected, as anything that happens is totally out of my control…you boys come across at times, personally stricken with any decision making by Cummins et al. We are fans, nothing more nothing less…as frustrating as it may be…
Teams realists support get praise or criticisms on their merits!
Comes with the territory and players must realise,they can’t have it both ways in being assessed.
Yeah,I can hear that old cliche coming out as a defence,that fans have never played the game at elite level,but rarely do they worry about that,when lavished with praise!
I don’t mind supporters being passionate for their tea,but when it’s blind passion where any criticism is seen as a “How Dare You ?”sling,the ones with blind faith,are the worst!
I’m sure you don’t fit into that category,but the reality is,thus Australian Team needs Major Surgery!
My point is Grassy, no one here is aware of what conversations were had or not had, about coin toss, selection, tactics, if any etc. Folk have a right to critique, got no probs with that, just find it strange some folk take it personally, and tee off like they are the ones it’s happening to with personal abuse…either support or don’t…it’s out of our control come end of the day.
My point is Constructive Criticusm isn’t Abuse!
I’ll support the Australian Cricket Team Always,NOT Blindly nor as a Happy Clapper!
Mate it is abuse when it gets personal and derogatory in nature…not constructive criticism. I get it folk are frustrated at that insipid performance by Aust, but not sure how Renshaw getting caught down the leg side first ball, Marnus leaving a ball hitting his stumps, or Inglis getting needlessly run out, Green charging down the wicket etc is due to a coin toss 4 days previous…that’s just poor shot selection, and school boy running between wickets…pretty sure no captain or coach tells any player/s to do that.
Harmer took 6/14, because the Aussies went into damage limitation for some reason, refused to rotate the strike, and play positively against him…the fella in the previous 2 tests had taken only 4 wickets @ 72 for christ sakes.
I have a subscription to Amazon Prime. They have the rights to all the ICC world cups and there are some good sports documentaries on it as well. They also have the “the Test” which has provided some access to Aussie tours since Justin Langers days as coach. Well look at this, they are making another series as per below
The streamer has confirmed a fourth season of its popular cricket behind-the-scenes docuseries The Test. The upcoming chapter will follow the Australia mens test cricket team on their packed 2026-27 schedule that includes daunting tours to South Africa, India, the one-off 150th Anniversary Test against England and the 2027 Ashes tour. Season four should be an intriguing watch as the Baggy Greens enter a period of transition, with many legends aging out and attempts to blood younger players proving a struggle thus far, all under the intense scrutiny of a demanding Aussie press and public.
Will be a very interesting watch in about 12 months and for a start will give some insight into some of the dressing room discussions that have taken place on this tour
Well I don’t fall into that category regarding the Cricket..
If you think others are,call 'em out!
On a Broadcasting Front,I’m getting a consensus of feedback.
KAO are USELESS!
Doesn’t affect me,but the crescendo of complaints seems to be getting louder.
I’m not sure there is personal abuse involved here
Important to remember these people are overpaid public figures
And in sport sometimes heated debate can emerge
As for abusive behaviour
I recall Quentin DeKock and David Warner exchanged some pretty awful insults
these involved sisters & wives and in full view of world cameras
the language was far past acceptable
Nowhere in here has there been the same levels of deliberate abuse or threats
It was in South Africa may have been the last tour there
Regular sledging of the poor kind is dished out between the two countries
I also recall Brian McMillan threatening to blow away the Australian side in another tour
These coaches and players cop heaps worse during games by crowds
“Coach Andrew McDonald says Australia’s batting is in a better place now than before the South Africa tour, despite admitting the team underperformed in the 2-1 series loss.”
“If you look at the batting unit, I think we walk away in a stronger position,” McDonald said.
“We’ve underachieved here,” McDonald said.
This guy is living an extravagant existence in his own head
@Southerner unfortunately some coaches dont have the guts to reverse a way of thinking, and this is a clear comment from one…That batting order is boom or bust and having lost 3 of the last 5 games we play that batting order is not ready to face India in India or the poms in the UK. I expect the poms are setting themselves for that series
Thing is PH, some of the suggestions for replacements put forward by the public on social media are borderline clown like as well, and these Einstein’s have the audacity to critique the folks in the hot seat …McSweeney, Peake, Jewell, Sangha, Morris, Meredith et al…it’s hilarious to read…all are bog average shield players, or chronically unfit, who can’t get on the park, and when they do, more often then not break down, or get out in the 20’s/30’s.
Even Ponting’s recent 2027 ODI WC squad is full of the current Test Dad’s Army folk, it is a laugh…and folk think RP is the next coming coach wise…and Ricky’s got 100+ tests more then the current selectors put together…be interesting to see the constructive criticism towards Ponting’s thoughts…
A slight aside.
Lance(Morris) - has he been playing sort of Cricket?
With CA’s “management”of his body,I can’t remember when he last played.
I’m amazed anyone outside WA has heard of him in the cricketing general public.
In fact,I’d be amazed if that many people here have heard of him.
Of course,thankfully his Club knows him,WA Cricket circles,us mugs,……
Ryan Harris should be the Australian coach.
BH does Harris have a connection with the current generation,of Players.
Ronald McDonald has just stated that an assestment.Of Labs will be made soon.
The potato should just be walked.And find some form in the Shield.
Things move slowly with the Captain,Coach+Selectors.